There’s a prevailing wisdom circulating among the commentary class when it comes to the Chicago Bears quarterback “competition”. If there’s no clear, discernible victor in these practice sessions, why not give Mitch Trubisky the start of the season, on a short leash, with Nick Foles warming in the bullpen?

But why wouldn’t the opposite approach be considered?

I’m not a very good billiards player, but I have spent thousands of hours in barrooms and so I’ve played far too many games of pool. Often, when the balls are all clumped together on the rail and I have no shot, I employ what I call the “poke and hope” method. I poke the cue ball at the clump and hope something productive happens.

This is what the Bears would be doing by starting Trubisky against the Detroit Lions. They don’t actually believe the light will turn on. They don’t believe Mitch is going to turn into a front line starter in the NFL. But they would be putting him out there and hoping something productive happens. If it does, great. If not, Foles.

But if starting a QB the first week does not mean committing to him for the duration of the season, why not start the more proven commodity in Foles? Why not start the player who can read defenses, get into the right plays/protections and – subsequently – get the football to the playmakers? Foles clearly doesn’t have the athletic upside of Trubisky but if his stable, veteran presence allows the offense to move the football and capitalize off one of the league’s best defenses, who cares?

Also, bringing Trubisky off the bench might actually dilute some of the pressure on the kid. If the Bears started Foles and went to Trubisky, one would have to assume either (a) Foles was hurt or (b) the Bears were losing too many games. Bringing Mitch into that scenario might allow him to play with the freedom he has lacked throughout his young career. Pressure comes from expectations. At 1-3, the expectations will be dramatically lower.

Folks who argue for starting Trubisky do so because they’re clinging to hope. But the Bears have a championship defense. They have a collection of skill guys capable of giving opposing defenses fits. Do the Bears want to risk even losing a single game…for hope?

With a week of practices almost in the books, I’ve actually started doing some “work” around here again, texting folks around the club to find out what’s happening. Here are some of their thoughts, and a lot of mine, in these early days.

The Lady’s Got Potential

Several people around practices have noted improvements in Mitch Trubisky’s footwork but let’s hit the breaks a bit. Does anybody care what a quarterback’s mechanics look like in practice sessions? Mitch can set his feet and throw at Halas Hall, I’ve no doubt about that. But can he set his feet and throw when those Smith boys from Green Bay are coming around the edge? If his mechanics are improved it’s undoubtedly a good thing. But nobody will know how improved until they start keeping score.

A New Argentina

Jimmy Graham was the best player on the practice field this week. Cole Kmet made his presence known immediately. There’s no reason to get overly excited about practices but it sure seems like the most improved position on the 2020 Bears will be tight end. Kmet is a stud. His early success won’t surprise me at all. Graham? As someone deep inside the organization told me this spring, “Ryan believes Jimmy is going to have a big season in this offense. So does Jimmy.” Soon, there might be some other believers around the league.

[Side note: I haven’t played fantasy football since Shaun Alexander was in the league but Jimmy Graham is someone I’d be looking at were I to play this season.]

The Art of the Possible

Note from a scout friend: “I think Tulane kid.. Mooney is going to be really good.“

Darnell Mooney can fly and the Bears think they stole a real player in the fifth round. Will he have major impact this season? Well, the truth is he doesn’t have to. With Teddy Ginn on the roster, the rookie can grow into the season and watched a seasoned speedster go about his work.

Read More …

Special thanks to the Q’s and Greta and all the folks at Merz Apothecary for partnering on a beard contest that was a somewhat ridiculous success. Each of our three winners below will be receiving various beard grooming products from them in the coming days. As the season approaches, we’ll keep thinking of creative ways to keep Merz part of what we do at DBB.

If you haven’t already, be sure to check out my appearance with the Merz team on their thrice weekly “Tea Time” program.

And while I’m by no means an expert on these things, I can’t endorse their ShamBar (shampoo bar) aggressively enough. My hair, and scalp, feel awesome using these and it’s going to save me hundreds of dollars in the coming year. The bars are available on the apothecary’s website by CLICKING HERE.

There will be a lot of discussion today about the #Bears‘ use of Cordarrelle Patterson at running back. Got a lot of reps there today.

— Adam Jahns (@adamjahns) August 17, 2020

The 2018 Chicago Bears were fun. They were so much fun that Noah Brier (dot com), the technology-minded former DJ responsible for this little website’s existence, reemerged in the underground dwelling known as Josie Woods, now with a young daughter reciting those famous words, “Bear down, Chicago Bears”. They were so much fun that I sat awake in a tiny Parisian hotel room, in the middle of the night, putting back 1664 tall boys and enthusiastically (but silently) cheering a primetime victory over the Vikings. (The experience all-but ruined the next day’s travel.) They were so much fun that Noah and I never even considered not going to Chicago for their home playoff game against the Eagles, cost be damned.

The 2018 Bears had defensive linemen in the backfield. A kid quarterback showing promise. Tarik Cohen looking borderline uncoverable by linebackers, safeties, anyone. Fake photoshoots in the end zone. Dance parties in the locker room. The team that had just suffered through the Greek tragedy of Marc Trestman and monotonously slow blood draining of John Fox’s tenure were giving joy to a fan base that had begun to view watching Bears games as a predictably joyless experience.

Then 2019 came. And the joylessness returned.

That’s why as the news began to surface the Bears planned to use Cordarrelle Pattersson in the back field, it was a breath of fresh air. Matt Nagy: “We want to be able to get the most of out of him…when you have weapons like that, you want to find ways to get them the ball.” This is a strikingly 2018 mentality. In 2018, Nagy knew what he didn’t have (yet, he thought) at the quarterback position and compensated with creativity. Folks considered these gimmicks but they clever devices designed to ask less of Mitch Trubisky. In 2019, he thought he had more at the position, thought Trubisky could effectively run his offense, and was caught flat-footed as a play caller because of that season-defining error.

Read More …

I was texting recently with a popular Bears beat writer recently. I won’t mention his name but it rhymes with the name of my favorite burlesque dancer, Madame Bombs. (The lyricist in me must stress that “Adam Jahns” does not technically rhyme with “Madame Bombs” but once I found that joke I was running with it.) This beat writer and I were both sharing a similar experience. Interest in the Chicago Bears, as we made our way through the early days of August, was almost non-existent. The sites aren’t getting the clicks. The tweets are getting the traction. The podcasts – and his is the best in the business – aren’t getting the ears.

Was it the absence of preseason football? Perhaps. For as silly as those games are, they serve as a sort of lighthouse for a desperate fan base out to sea. We’re not on land yet but we know land approaches. Was it the lack of a fan-attended training camp? Perhaps. Normally, by now, we’ve seen a hundred fan videos of players in shorts and I’d have received a dozen emails with subject lines like “Watch out for Ryan Nall”. In the absence of the season’s build-up, we’re left with two of the world’s great bores: mindless social media debate and baseball.

100%. Surreal. https://t.co/uzxqjrEMlP

— DaBearsBlog (@dabearsblog) August 14, 2020

Today could change that, as the beat writer pointed out to me. Today is the first day the media will attend Chicago Bears practice, the first time Madame Bombs and his cohorts will get to weigh-in on the quarterback “competition”. Today they might be able to tell us if Jaylon Johnson is running with the ones, or who has the leg up at right guard. Today and tomorrow there will be a flurry of Bears coverage with actual observations, information and insight, as opposed to blind predictions, what ifs and rankings of inactive game day quarterbacks from across the league. (As entertaining as that piece was from Fishbain, it left me with a “why did I just read that” feeling afterwards.)

Read More …

Today at noon CT, I’ll be appearing on the daily Tea Time at the Apothecary with the folks from Merz Apothecary, as we’ll be discussing our developing partnership and evaluating the finalist beards for our first giveaway. (There were many terrific submissions.)

Here’s how to watch:

Twitter: @MerzApothecary

Facebook: LIVE

And if you can’t watch either of these live, I’ll have the video of the conversation up on this site this afternoon.

The quotes came from new Bears quarterbacks coach John DeFilippo.

“At the end of the day, which guy’s raising the other ten guys’ level.”

“At the end of the day, it’s who moves our football team and converts on third down.”

Question. One word. When?

When is this raising of the other ten guys’ level happening?

When is the football team being moved?

When are these third downs being converted?

I might be having an Allen Iverson moment but…practice? We talking about…practice?

Quarterbacks are always the story in the NFL and a quarterback competition over the summer is the juiciest story there is for hungry football writers. But there are three things fans must consider before investing too much into this battle.

(1) Without preseason games, there won’t be anything resembling an obvious winner. Preseason games would have allowed the whole of the football world to evaluate the play of these two men and accurately assess which gave the Bears the best chance to win. Preseason games would have made fans active participants in the competition, enabling them to generate their own thoughts and opinions based on the palpable data of performance.

(2) The media will have their say on the competition but most of the important moments in camp practices, the parts where the actual game plan is installed and executed, happen after the media is sent away. You’ll learn far more from Adam Jahns’ insider reporting on Nagy’s thoughts than Brad Biggs’ impressions from a few passing drills.

Read More …